Abstract
The present study was conducted to investigate the effect of whispering and changes in intensity of voice on the frequency of stuttering and the rate of speech. Nine stutterers read under four experimental conditions. Condition A (reading in whispering), condition B (reading at 60dB SPL), condition C (reading at 70dB SPL) and condition D (reading at 80dB SPL). Results showed that stuttering was significantly reduced with increase in intensity and stutterers became more fluent when they whispered. Rate of speech was significantly reduced in all conditions in which stuttering was significantly reduced. The results are discussed and explained on the basis of enhanced laryngeal feedback. Stuttering has been explained in many ways and the literature on theories of stuttering run into volumes. But no one theory explains satisfactorily all the aspects of stuttering. The recent investigations concerning the cause and nature of stuttering emphasize on the role of phonatory behaviour in stuttering. Larynn has been held responsible for stuttering to occur. A number of studies have directly or indirectly indicated phonatory involve- ment in stuttering (Adams and Hayden 1976, Adams and Reis 1971,1974, Adams et al,1976, Agneilo and Wingate 1971, Agnello, Wingate and Wendell 1974, Brennel, Perkins and Soderberg 1972, Charie Muller 1963, Conture et al,1974, Freeman and Ushijima 1978, Fujita 1966, Manning and Coujal 1976, Schwartz 1974, Stackweather et al, 1976, Wingate 1969b, Wyke 1974). Wingate (1969), after an analysis of various conditions under which stutterers enjoy 'artificial fluency' inferred that 'vocalization' is a crucial element in stuttering. Wingate (1970) further argued that reduction in stuttering associated with changes in audition is due to changes induced in vocalization. Adams and Moore (1972), and Adams and Hutchinson (1974), observed that as the intensity of mask- ing noise was increased, stutterers became more fluent, increased their vocal intensity and spoke at slower speech rates. Several authors have reported that stuttering is markedly reduced during whispering (Johnsen and Rosen 1937, Bloodstein 1950, Van Riper 1971, Perkins, Rudas and Bell 1976, Commodore and Cooper, 1978). investigated the effect of varying intensity on stuttering. Twenty-eight stutterers read a passage containing all voiced phonemes and a passage containing both voice and voiceless phonemes under three conditions, soft voice, normal voice and aloud voice when 75dBSPL of white noise was presented through earphones. More stuttering was observed in normal voice condition with all voiced phoneme prose. Stuttering was reduced while using soft voice and while using loud voice. The literature suggests that phonation is an important factor in stuttering and changes in certain aspects of phonation bring about significant changes in the frequency of stuttering. Therefore, in this study it was proposed to investigate the influence of whispering and the influence of varying intensity of voice on stuttering. Ramig (1980), studied the effect of varying pitch on the frequency of stuttering. He found a significant reduction in stuttering with reduction in reading rate as the stutterers varied their picth above and below their habitual pitch. Reis (1974),
References
Adams, M. R., and Reis, R., ' The influence of onset of phonation on the frequency of stuttering '. J. Speech Hearing Res., 14, 639-644 (1971).
Adams, M. R., and Reis, R., 'Influence of onset of phonation on the frequency of stuttering—A replication and re-evaluation' (letter to the editor).
J.'Speech Hearing Res., 17, 752-754 (1974).
Adams, M.R., Riemenschneider, S., Metz, D. E., Conture, E. G., ' Voice onset and articulatory constructions requirements in a speech segment and their relation to the amount of stuttering adaptation', Jf. Fluency Dis., 1, 24-31 (1976).
Agnello, J. G., and Wingate, M. E.i ' Some acoustical and physiological aspects of stuttered speech '. Paper presented at the Annual Convention of ASHA, San Fransisco, 1972.
Agnello, J.G., Wingate, M. E., and Wendell, M., 'Voice onset and voice termination times of children and adult stutterers'. Paper presented at the Annual Convention of ASHA, St. Louis, (1974).
Adams, M. R., and Moore, W. H. , Th e effects of auditory masking on the anxiety level frequency of disfluency and selected vocal characteristics of stutterers '. J. Speech Hearing, Res., 15, 572-578 (1972).
Adams, MR . and Hutchinson, J., 'Th e effects of three levels of auditory masking on selected. vocal characteristics and the frequency of disfluency of adult stutterers.' J. Speech Hearing Res., 17, 682-688 (1974).
Atkinson (1962) in Zemlin W. R.,' Speech and Hearing Science, Anatomy and Physiology. Prentice Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey (1968).
Bloodstein O., 'A rating scale study of conditions under which stuttering is reduced or absent'. J. Speech Hearing Dis.-,15, 29-36 (1950).
Brennel M. 0. , Perkins, W. H., and Soderberg, G. A., ' The effect of rehearsal on the frequency of stuttering'. J. Speech Hearing Res., 15, 483-486 (1972).
Chernic-Muller, C, ' A Study of the laryngeal function in stutterers by the glottal graphic method ' (1963). Quoted by, Freeman and Ushijima (1978).
Commodore, R. W., and Cooper, E. B., ' Communicative stress and stuttering frequency during normal, whispered and articultaion without phonation modes '. J. Fluency Dis., 3, 1-12 (1978).
Conture, E. G., McCall, G. P., and Brewer, D. W., 'Laryngeal activity during the moment of stuttering, some preliminary observations '. Paper presented at the Annual Convention of ASHA, Los Vegas (1974).
Fransworth (1940) in Zemlin, W. R., Speech and Hearing Science: Anatomy and Physiology. Prentice Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey (1968).
Freeman, F. J.3 and Ushijima, T. , 'Laryngeal muscle activity during stuttering'. j . Speech Hearing Res., 21, 538-562 (1978).
Fujita, K., Pathophysiology of the larynx from the view point of phonation. jf. Japan Society of Otorhinolaryngology, 69, 459 (1966).
Gerber, S. F., and Martin, R., ' Effects of noise and increased vocal intensity on stuttering', J. Speech Hearing Res., 20, 233-239 (1977).
Goldstein (1942) Quoted in Kinsbourne M., ' Cognitive deficit and the unity of brain organisaticn, Goldsteins perspective updated'. J. Commun. Dis., 14, 181-195 (1981).
Johnson, W., and Rosen, L., ' Studies on the psychology of stuttering VII, effect of certain changes in speech pattern upon frequency of stuttering'. jf. Speech Dis., 2, 105-109 (1937).
Kinsbourne, M., ' Cognitive deficit and the unity of brain organisation, Goldsteins perspective updated', J. Commun. Dis., 14, 181-195 (1981).
Manning, W. H., and Confal, R. J., ' The frequency of disfluencies during phonatory transitions in stuttered and non-stuttered speech', jf. Commun. Dis., 9, 75-81 (1976).
Margariet Boels—Van Dijk, ' Distraction in the treatment of stuttering ', in Lebrun Y., and Hoops, R., (ed)Neurolinguistic approaches to stuttering. Proceedings of the international symposium on stuttering (Brussels, 1972).
Perkins, W., Rudds, J., Johnson, L., and Bell, J., ' Stuttering: Discoordination of phonation with articulation and respiration'. j of. Speech Hearing Res., 19, 509-521 (1976).
Ramig, P., and Adams, M. R., ' Rate reduction strategies used by stutterers during high and low- pitched speech ' j of. Fluency Dis., 5, 27-41 (1980).
Reis, R. P., ' The effects of selected vocal characteristics on stuttering frequency and oral reading times of stutterers ', ASHA, 16, 521 (1974).
Schwartz., M. F., ' The core of the stuttering block 'j of. Speech Hearing Dis., 39, 169-177 (1974).
Siegal, S., Non-parametric statistics for the behavioral sciences. Tokyo, McGraw Hill, Kogakusha (1956).
Starkweather, C. W., Hirschman, P., and Tannenbaum, R. S., 'Latency of vocalization onset: Stutterers Vs. Non-stutterers'. j of. Speech Hearing Res., 19, 481-492 (1976).
Van Riper, C, The nature of stuttering. Englewood Cliffs, N. J: Prentice Hall (1971).
Wingate, M. E., 'Sound pattern in " artificial" fluency', j of. Speech Hearing Res., 12, 677-686 (1969b) .
Wingate, M. E., ' Of changes in Audition on stuttering', j. of Speech Hearing Disorder.
Wyke, B., 'Phonatory reflex mechanism and stammering'. Folia phoniatrica, 26, 321-328 (1974).
Zemlin, W. R., Speech and Hearing Science: Anatomy and physiology, Prentice Hall Inc., Engle-wood Cliffs, New Jersey (1968).